EVs Can Be 'Worse' Than Gas Cars, and That's Perfectly Fine

Electric vehicles can serve as the accessible and dependable means of transport we require. However, this is true only if we cease attempting to confine them within the framework designed for gasoline-powered cars.

China’s leadership in the electric vehicle (EV) market can be attributed to several familiar factors. The country invested significant governmental funds into this sector, streamlined bureaucratic processes, offered incentives to consumers, and made land more affordable. Local firms, which had little to no background in manufacturing internal combustion engine (ICE) vehicles, viewed this shift as a chance rather than a burden, unlike numerous Western enterprises that see it primarily as a challenge. However, one aspect remains both understated yet crucial.

A A much greater percentage of Chinese individuals purchasing electric vehicles are doing so for their first car. Many people previously owned just one or two vehicles. This is crucial because in China, electric vehicles came without most of the issues that continue to burden them in other places.

Photo by: InsideEVs

Ford’s CEO has recently stated that the economics of large electric SUVs are “unsolvable.” I concur with this view, so I believe that extended-range vehicles and hybrid models will continue to dominate these market segments for an extended period.

In 2022, the typical purchaser of a new car in the United States was approximately 51 years old. per Cox Automotive Even typical buyers of used cars were around 49 years old, with both demographics boasting incomes above average. This indicates they are comparatively affluent individuals who came of age in an era where automobiles played a dominant role. Growing up surrounded by vehicles powered by internal combustion engines, many also recall a time when air travel was considerably more expensive and less common. Consequently, nearly all have vivid memories of family excursions taken in gasoline-powered cars. Throughout much of their adulthood, these individuals primarily bought gasoline-fueled vehicles and depended heavily on them for transportation needs.

{getCard} $type={post} $title={You might like}

Currently, they are being informed that electric vehicles will soon take over their market. However, for large, bulky vehicles that most consumers are used to purchasing, embarking on long trips necessitates paying significantly higher initial costs, using multiple planning and charging applications, and enduring a more time-consuming and challenging driving process. These customers are now advised to purchase from the same company that previously provided gasoline-powered cars an updated version of familiar models at increased prices and generally lower overall efficiency. worse reliability .

So of course they're pissed off.

I know I am. When looking to substitute a $2,500 Chevy Tahoe for camping trips, I decided to lease a Chevy Blazer EV instead. I enjoy cruising around the city with it, but the ecological tires restrict its ability to handle unpaved terrain. The seats aren’t able to be folded completely flat, which means I can't use it for sleeping during camping trips like I do with my Tahoe. During a 1,000-mile round trip to Utah, I spent hours trying to keep it charged. .

I missed out on seeing an incredible viewpoint at Bryce Canyon due to range anxiety and having just one of the required Tesla charging adaptors. The adapter I possessed was insufficient. permitted me to utilize Superchargers , yet this meant I had to park my vehicle across two spaces, making me appear rather rude. What really stood out: Given that the charging rates at numerous stations were between $0.53 and $0.65 per kWh, I ended up not saving anything compared to completing the journey with a gasoline-powered crossover.

The experience sucks.

I haven't come across a direct equivalent in terms of electric vehicles (EVs) for this, as honestly speaking, the notion of someone who is 27 years old without children needing to drive an SUV large enough to serve as a makeshift bedroom seems ridiculous. There isn’t really a place for an EV version of such a vehicle.

If you’re coming at this from the perspective of a gasoline-powered vehicle, I understand completely. You might be thinking about long road trips. Or perhaps driving deep into remote areas. Maybe you imagine summertime journeys like traveling from Cleveland to Hilton Head—covering around 14 hours. And let’s not forget dealing with cranky children at service stations, along with all the challenges of adapting to a method that your old gas-guzzler handled effortlessly years ago.

However, an electric vehicle is not like a gasoline-powered car; they have distinct differences. This implies that there’s a completely different set of compromises involved, as extensively discussed: today’s models tend to be either overly pricey or poor for long-distance travel.

Photo by: Mack Hogan/InsideEVs

I enjoy driving my Blazer EV, yet I wouldn’t have forked over the $52,000 listed price. Instead, I acquired it through a lease deal costing me $273 per month plus an upfront payment of $2,000; both the dealership and GM absorbed some losses here. This suggests that high-priced electric vehicles might not be attracting buyers based purely on their quality alone.

These two issues are interconnected. When electric vehicles are freed from the requirement for long-distance travel, all other concerns tend to diminish.

Drive the Blazer instead. The experiences I detailed thoroughly account for three full days out of roughly eight months since acquiring the vehicle. These instances pushed the limits of rare occurrences. There was a 1,000-mile journey into rural America involved. This represents the quintessential American road trip experience shared by so many. Nonetheless, such adventures do not reflect the main purpose we use this car for most often. Having resided in California for around three years, this has been just the second occasion where I traveled over 500 miles at once. Far more common excursions include visits to Joshua Tree National Park and Anza Borrego Desert State Park—destinations comfortably accessible with the Blazer. Still, even those jaunts remain exceptional events.

Even though advertisements often depict rugged mountain paths and emphasize features like towing capacity, speed, or exploring uncharted territories, these scenarios likely account for only about ten percent of your vehicle’s actual usage. Most often, it simply gets you to work, school, visits with friends, or nearby towns. There isn’t much in the way of epic adventures; it merely transports you between locations routinely.

Listen, it would be awesome if everyday life felt like this. However, in trying to address extremely rare scenarios—such as people driving large luxury SUVs off-road—the Hummer EV ended up becoming pricier, more outlandish, and significantly heavier. Perhaps we could let hybrids and extended-range electric vehicles handle rock crawling instead.

In all these scenarios, an electric vehicle (EV) offers superior benefits. However, concentrating on long-distance travel has somewhat diminished this edge. Electric vehicles demand minimal routine upkeep due to their enclosed motors and less complex drive systems. Nevertheless, when you adapt an EV for extended journeys, it needs to be heavier, leading to higher tire costs. The straightforward design of EVs typically allows them to be manufactured at a lower cost as well. Nonetheless, as expected, the substantial battery drives up the price, making it $15,000 dearer than its gasoline counterpart.

I understand, I understand. need To embark on that road trip. Although it occurs annually, it is crucial, regardless of the reason. Believe me, I have no intention of seeking you out. Instead, my message is this: Allow gasoline to manage these tasks for now. Offer extended-range EVs , as well as hybrid and even traditional gasoline-powered drivetrains for those who often embark on lengthy journeys. Gasoline trucks are remarkable vehicles, and it will be some time before any electric vehicle can match the Ford F-150’s capabilities at the same cost point. Let the internal combustion engines tackle the cross-country drives; rest assured, they’re up to the task.

Photo by: Ford

The Lightning is an excellent pickup, yet it remains a hard sell compared to a gasoline-powered F-150 that offers lower costs and superior towing capabilities regardless of location.

This will allow electric vehicle designers to concentrate on the genuine benefits of this shift. Car manufacturers are opting to produce range-extender EVs equipped with smaller batteries and gasoline powertrains for extended driving capacity. Additionally, they may provide a premium all-electric option boasting several hundred miles of range.

Reverse this approach. Provide the same compact battery option for both choices. Equip the electric vehicle with a 150-mile range and highlight long-distance travel as an additional feature. Consider offering rental services for range extenders or extra battery units. Service centers at dealerships will likely seek new avenues to keep themselves occupied as electric vehicles rapidly surpass internal combustion engine reliability.

Provide us affordable electric vehicles that still manage to be thrilling. While buyers might have dismissed the Nissan Leaf and Mini Cooper SE, did planners ever think about the fact that Americans generally avoid buying hatchbacks, irrespective of their power source? Consider offering a compact SUV instead—a model spacious enough to transport your mountain bike into the wilderness—but keep the starting price around $30,000 before incentives. If Chevrolet can deliver a 319-mile Range Rover EV priced at $35,000, then achieving even better value seems feasible.

The Chevy Bolt can easily tackle daily commutes and even accommodate medium-distance road trips. Should someone succeed in giving it more appealing design than a laser printer, this could become the electric vehicle for the masses that we've been waiting for.

Create a luxurious variant as well. If possible, I wouldn’t mind keeping my old, worn-out gasoline pickup indefinitely, provided that my everyday car could be a sleek, leather-clad electric vehicle equipped with top-notch audio systems and seating. Given the minimalist approach with compact motors and batteries, high-end finishes ought to become easier to integrate into such designs. Also, produce an all-electric Ford Ranger; suggest opting for the hybrid model only if long-distance travel is necessary. For most uses, the EV offers a cost-effective, straightforward, and refined alternative rather than serving as an exact replica of something that’s almost perfect already.

Electric vehicles are already gaining traction in the commercial van market, as purchasers in this category prioritize their daily needs over an infrequent annual journey.

This presents an occasion for reinvention. However, it necessitates moving away from viewing electric vehicles (EVs) merely as superior or inferior alternatives to those powered by gasoline. Instead, we should see them as a distinct form of transport. They won’t completely supplant gasoline-powered options across all scenarios—at least not currently. Yet, for our everyday lives and for approximately 90 percent of the distance we typically cover, they represent the perfect choice.

Electric vehicles aren't like gasoline cars. This is a positive aspect.

Previous Post Next Post